The disbelief inside Clemson’s fanbase is thick enough to taste.
Just four weeks into the 2025 college football season, Clemson, a perennial powerhouse in the 2010s, two-time national champion under Dabo Swinney, and a preseason favorite to win the ACC have collapsed into chaos.
Former Georgia quarterback turned ESPN college football analyst Aaron Murray shared his views as to what’s going on inside and outside the program.
“The low-hanging fruit is Clemson. I picked Clemson to win the national championship,” Murray said on the Always College Football podcast. “But it’s the way they’re losing. I mean, they are getting just punched in the mouth upfront.
“You’re supposed to be Clemson. You’re supposed to be this elite team with all this talent, and you’re getting blown off the ball in your home stadium.”
Murray’s assessment was scathing, but the numbers back him up.
Clemson’s defense, once the pride of the program and a factory for NFL talent, has struggled to stop even average attacks.
The defensive line, loaded with supposed first-round picks, has been bullied at the line of scrimmage.
Even Syracuse, a team rarely confused for a juggernaut, manhandled the Tigers in a 34-21 win in Death Valley. It was a beatdown so thorough that longtime observers called it the worst home performance of the Swinney era.
The Tigers’ 1-3 start has not only stunned the football world but has unleashed a torrent of criticism that threatens to reshape the future of the program and its head coach.
Few could have predicted the scope of Clemson’s unraveling. The Tigers began the season with a narrow but respectable loss to LSU, followed by a routine win against Troy.
What came next was something out of a fever dream for the Clemson faithful: back-to-back ACC defeats at the hands of Georgia Tech and Syracuse. Each loss seemed to sap more confidence from the team, and more patience from a fan base accustomed to dominance, not desperation.
Not only is the Tigers defense not showing up, quarterback Cade Klubnik, the latest handpicked signal-caller to follow in the footsteps of Deshaun Watson and Trevor Lawrence, has been erratic.
The offense has sputtered, unable to finish drives or establish an identity.
“The quarterback has been inconsistent throwing the football. All things I thought Clemson was going to be this year, they’re not,” Murray said. “So, I’m surprised about that.”
For Swinney, the criticism has clearly struck a nerve. In the wake of the Syracuse loss, he fired back at doubters during a lengthy, emotional press conference.
“If Clemson’s tired of winning, they can send me on my way, but I’m gonna go somewhere else and coach,” Swinney insisted, his voice tinged with both defiance and fatigue. “That’s all we’ve done is win.”
But sentiment on campus and on social media has shifted dramatically.
Once the architect of one of college football’s most remarkable turnarounds including two national titles, six consecutive College Football Playoff appearances, Swinney is now facing questions about his ability to adapt.
His resistance to the transfer portal, his loyalty to staff, and his old-school approach have gone from endearing to infuriating for many fans and analysts.
The Tigers’ fall from national title contender to conference afterthought has also exposed a new reality in the ACC. Programs like Georgia Tech and Syracuse, once easy marks for the Tigers, now see Clemson as vulnerable prey.
“I love Georgia Tech and I love Syracuse and what Fran Brown is doing, but you’re supposed to be Clemson,” Murray said. “You’re supposed to be this elite team with all this talent, and you’re getting blown off the ball in your home stadium.”
The near-term outlook is grim. With two conference losses and another gauntlet of ACC games ahead, Clemson is all but mathematically eliminated from any meaningful postseason goals (Shakin the Southland). The program enters its bye week not as a sleeping giant, but as a team searching for answers to basic questions of identity and purpose.
For Swinney, the next steps are daunting. He must find a way to reset his team physically and mentally while ignoring the mounting noise from the outside. “Losses suck, but the way they’re losing is just mind-blowing to me.
“It’s embarrassing. I’d be embarrassed if I was a Clemson fan,” Murray repeated. “You are what you put on tape. It’s been four weeks of that. I don’t know if you can really change it. You are who you are right now, and it’s not a physical team.”
Some see parallels to other fallen dynasties, where stubbornness and loyalty became liabilities rather than strengths.
Yet, for all the doom surrounding Clemson, there remains the faintest glimmer of hope for a course correction.
The Tigers’ next game, against a similarly struggling North Carolina team, offers a chance for a reset.
Whether Swinney and his staff can seize that opportunity, or whether the program’s downward spiral will continue, may determine not just the fate of the 2025 season, but the very future of one of college football’s modern day dynasties.
About the Author
